How to grade an hour green, amber, or red
To grade an hour, write one honest sentence about what it was, then ask whether you'd choose it again. Green means lived well, amber means neutral, red means wasted. Judge intention, not output — rest and people count as green.
Grading an hour sounds like it should be complicated. It isn't. You write one honest sentence about what the hour was, then you give it a color — and the color comes from a single question you can answer in seconds.
The one question that decides the color
Every grade comes down to this: would I choose this hour again?
Not "was I busy," not "did I produce something." Just whether, knowing how the hour actually went, you'd spend it the same way. That question does the sorting for you:
- Green — lived well. A clear yes. The hour was worth a piece of a life you don't get back.
- Amber — neutral. A shrug. It wasn't wasted, but you wouldn't frame it either. The necessary middle of most days.
- Red — wasted. A clear no. Time you'd take back if you could, or an hour you can't even account for.
The trick is answering honestly and quickly. The first instinct is usually right; the second one is you negotiating. If you find yourself building a case for green, it's probably amber.
Write the sentence first
Before you pick a color, write one plain sentence about what the hour actually was. "Deep work on the proposal." "Scrolled through my phone in bed." "Long lunch with Dad." The sentence matters as much as the grade — it's the honest record that stops memory from editing the day into the version you'd prefer.
The sentence also makes the color easier. Once the hour is named in flat, unflattering language, its grade tends to be obvious. "Half-watched a show while checking email" doesn't argue very hard for green.
What counts as green
This is where most people grade themselves wrong, so it's worth being precise. Green is not a productivity score. It rewards intention, not output.
An hour is green if you'd choose it again — and that includes far more than work:
- Deep, focused effort on something that mattered.
- Real rest: a nap, a walk, sitting still on purpose.
- People: a conversation, a meal, time with someone you love.
- Play: a hobby, a game, something done purely because you wanted to.
A slow morning you actually chose is greener than a frantic day of busywork you'll forget by Friday. If you only ever grade "productive" hours green, you've built a spreadsheet, not a picture of a life. This is the line at the heart of hour grading: lived versus lost, not busy versus idle.
What counts as red
See how you actually spend your hours.
Grade each hour green, amber or red — free, no signup.
Red is for the two ways an hour is genuinely lost:
- Wasted. Doomscrolling, aimless tabs, half-watching something you weren't enjoying — time that pulled you along rather than time you spent.
- Unaccounted. The hour you honestly can't reconstruct. If it's a blank, it's red, or at best amber. Resist the urge to fill blanks with a generous guess.
Red is not a moral failure, and a day with red in it is a normal day. The point of naming it is not guilt — it's that a repeated red hour at the same time each day is a pattern you can actually change once you can see it.
Where amber lives
Amber is the honest middle, and most days are full of it. Admin, email, chores, the commute, the maintenance that keeps a life running — none of it is wasted, but you wouldn't frame it either.
Don't try to eliminate amber. A day scrubbed of all neutral hours isn't a good day; it's an exhausting one. The goal is to see amber clearly, not to feel bad about it.
A quick reference
When you're unsure, this table settles most cases in a second:
Edge cases and honest calls
A few situations trip people up:
- Interrupted hours. Grade the dominant feel of the hour. If forty minutes were focused and twenty were lost, it's probably still green — but if the interruption defined it, be honest.
- Guilty pleasures. A show you genuinely wanted to watch and enjoyed is green. The test is intention, not whether it looks impressive on a grid.
- Work you resent. Necessary work you'd still choose is amber or green. Work you're only doing because you failed to say no is closer to red — the grade is information about your week, not a punishment.
- The bad day. Some days are mostly red. Grade them that way. A run of honest red days is more useful than a smooth wall of flattering green.
Why the color matters more over time
One graded hour tells you almost nothing. A month of them tells you the truth. As the hours fill in, the month color grid stops being a chore and becomes a mirror — you can see a good week and a bad one at a glance, and the pattern updates itself without you having to remember anything.
That's the whole reason to grade honestly rather than kindly. Zoom out far enough and the life-in-weeks view makes the stakes plain: the hours are numbered, so it's worth knowing which ones you'd choose again.
If you're just starting, walk through your first seven days with hour grading for beginners, and if you want the colors themselves defined in more depth, see what the hour colors actually mean. For the full method underneath all of it, start with the pillar guide on how to grade your hours. You can also just open the app and grade the hour you're in right now.
FAQ
What is the fastest way to grade an hour?
Ask one question: would you choose this hour again? A clear yes is green, a clear no is red, and a genuine shrug is amber. The whole judgment should take about five seconds.
Does resting count as a green hour?
Yes. Real rest, a meal, a walk, or time with someone you love all count as lived. Green rewards intention, not productivity — a slow morning you chose is greener than a frantic hour of busywork.
What if I can't remember what I did?
That hour is red, or at best amber. Unaccounted time is one of the two ways an hour is lost, so grade it honestly rather than guessing kindly. The blank spots are often the most useful thing the grid shows you.
Should I grade every single hour?
No. Grade your waking hours as you go, and don't worry about missed ones. A day that is mostly graded still reveals the pattern; perfect coverage is not the point.
Is amber a bad grade?
No. Amber is honest, and most days have plenty of amber hours. It marks the neutral maintenance that keeps a life running — the goal is to see it clearly, not to eliminate it.
Keep reading
Hour grading for beginners: a first-week walkthrough
New to hour grading? Here's exactly what to do in your first week: one honest sentence per hour, a green, amber or red mark, and reading the pattern.
What the green, amber, and red hour colors actually mean
Green, amber, and red hours mean lived well, neutral, and lost. Here's what each color really stands for, and how to grade an hour without overthinking it.
Grading work vs leisure: is relaxing a lived hour?
Yes — rest can be a green hour. What decides is intention, not whether you were working. Here's how to grade work and leisure honestly.
New here? Start with the How to grade your hours guide.
Start counting your hours.
Free, no signup. Your hours are saved on your device.